Reviews

Never found truly great BBQ up north... until this place. Great smoked meat!

Stacia Passaro via facebook.com - May 13, 2020

Delicious authentic BBQ, friendly amazing staff, warm welcoming comfortable family- friendly atmosp

Delicious authentic BBQ, friendly amazing staff, warm welcoming comfortable family- friendly atmosphere, and fantastic live music on Fridays & Saturdays!!!

Jon Bates via facebook.com - May 1, 2020

Great food and service. Love the ...

Great food and service. Love the fried chicken. Service was very well done. Came right to the car as soon as you pull in so there was no confusion. Thank you Brothers bbq!

Rosemarie S. via yelp.com - Apr 30, 2020

I recommend Brothers Barbecue Restaraunt, because the food is awesome, tasteful, no matter what mea

I recommend Brothers Barbecue Restaraunt, because the food is awesome, tasteful, no matter what meal you order the customer will come back for more. The wings and fried chicken can’t forget the pulled pork is tasty especially the barbecue sauce mmm. The Brothers and the staff are very friendly and will accommodate their customers t ... read more

Salina Walker via facebook.com - Apr 21, 2020

Brothers BBQ has really pivoted to feed us all with soul food safely and efficiently as we shelter

Brothers BBQ has really pivoted to feed us all with soul food safely and efficiently as we shelter in place! Brilliant!

Will Juntunen via facebook.com - Apr 20, 2020

Ordered through GrubHub, based on calling the phone number, thirty minutes later, while I am sittin

Ordered through GrubHub, based on calling the phone number, thirty minutes later, while I am sitting in the parking lot, I get a text that the order was cancelled, needless to say I was furious. Spoke with the chef who apologized and filled the order for us. I would make the suggestion that you have an alternate greeting for when y ... read more

April Dawn Riley via facebook.com - Apr 12, 2020

Absolutely delicious 😋 and they have a great set up to keep us all safe with curb side pick up.

Laurie Owen via facebook.com - Apr 1, 2020

I have about 60 guys that are away from their families here in Montgomery working to help fill the

I have about 60 guys that are away from their families here in Montgomery working to help fill the grocery stores in the local area. My guys have been working almost 90 hours a week to ensure families have a place to shop during this Virus. And due to a last minute catering cancellation, I called Brothers Barbecue and they came throu ... read more

Chase Thompson via facebook.com - Mar 29, 2020

with this crazy pandemic going on we are so glad Brothers offers curb side delivery , we ordered th

with this crazy pandemic going on we are so glad Brothers offers curb side delivery , we ordered the chicken sandwich with cole slaw, mac and cheese baked beans ! with the side of brothers sauce .The food was absolutely amazing ..The chicken sandwich is fantastic ... read more

Tara Lynn via facebook.com - Mar 28, 2020

I don't even know what to say....it is that good

I don't even know what to say....it is that good ... read more

Nyree Collins via facebook.com - Mar 14, 2020

This little gem in Orange County ...

This little gem in Orange County ( new Windsor) is worth the stop. The outside may not look like much but the inside is very nice with a bar and fireplace the food is good and the people are warm and don't forget that cornbread so delicious
Sorry Guys i forgot to take pictures ... read more

Shaunte W. via yelp.com - Mar 14, 2020

Absolutely the best barbecue I've ...

Absolutely the best barbecue I've ever eaten. The wings are to die for and they have a fried shrimp dinner that is better than the shrimp you would get at a good seafood restaurant. Do not hesitate to try this place. It may not look like fine dining, but the dining is real fine!

Jimbo C. via yelp.com - Mar 8, 2020

very friendly staff and great selection of sides and main dishes

very friendly staff and great selection of sides and main dishes ... read more

Mike Hicks via facebook.com - Mar 8, 2020

Hands down the best BBQ we've had ...

Hands down the best BBQ we've had in this area and we've been looking for a good place! Family friendly and good live music. A big too bright inside (my idea of a BBQ blues joint is a little dimmer) but that is the only downside.

Kusemono M. via yelp.com - Mar 7, 2020

Great bbq and family friendly...

Debbie Shea-Schiraldi via facebook.com - Mar 7, 2020

SO GOOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Michael Tillotson via facebook.com - Mar 6, 2020

Great pizza ... read more

Matt F via google.com - Mar 4, 2020

Stocking up on the absolute best bbq sauce! Awesome customer service and amazing food!

Joe Thompson via facebook.com - Mar 2, 2020

Great food! Try the Whiskey Bread pudding dessert!!

Betsy Lansdell Sharo via facebook.com - Feb 27, 2020

The food was good large portions. I decided to go with apps versus a meal, I order 3 apps WAYYY too

The food was good large portions. I decided to go with apps versus a meal, I order 3 apps WAYYY too much for 1. I enjoyed it the staff was friendly and nice atmosphere. My only issue the music was alittle down it was the blues and it made me alittle blue (did you see what I did there lol) Very enjoyable ... read more

Shawn C. Hobson via facebook.com - Feb 23, 2020

I hate pickles but by some kitchen ...

I hate pickles but by some kitchen magic that is going on at Brothers, I would eat a bucket of theirs. They are monumental! Every time we have been here, we've been so pleased. If you leave hungry, it's your own fault! The portions are huge! Tip: when ordering the loaded fries, bring 2 friends!

Jill L. via yelp.com - Feb 23, 2020

Great food, large portions, friendly wait staff

Great food, large portions, friendly wait staff ... read more

Shonna Nicole via facebook.com - Feb 23, 2020

Everything is delicious. Been ...

Everything is delicious. Been going for years and they are the real deal. Fantastic bbq, wings, fried chicken I could go on and on.

Patricia B. via yelp.com - Feb 22, 2020

Not being from the area, my boyfriend ...

Not being from the area, my boyfriend and I found Brothers from a google search and we're glad we did. The wait time was not long and the atmosphere was great. They had live music that evening which was fun. The food was delicious! I had the fried chicken with mac and cheese and candied yams which was soooo good! My boyfriend ordered ... read more

Maria R. via yelp.com - Feb 21, 2020

Great food great great service

Great food great great service ... read more

Joseph Melville via facebook.com - Feb 21, 2020

I just had the Bro Ribber and it was outstanding!

Ian Jason Genao via facebook.com - Feb 19, 2020

A great place to dine and relax - great staff and food

A great place to dine and relax - great staff and food ... read more

Joseph Volkmer via facebook.com - Feb 18, 2020

We were hungry and they understood exactly what we needed! Fix your meat craving no doubt...

Chamille Thayer via facebook.com - Feb 16, 2020

Best BBQ around

Brothers BBQ is a must go place. Great selections of real BBQ done right. Unbeatable service and always a great experience. Never had a bad meal.

Bbqman1967 via tripadvisor.com - Feb 11, 2020

Great food and service! The brisket is so, so tender!

Michelle Pomarico via facebook.com - Feb 9, 2020

food was excellent and a good portion.waitress was great, timed the service and was attentive to d

food was excellent and a good portion. waitress was great, timed the service and was attentive to drink refills.

Al Pfingstl via facebook.com - Feb 8, 2020

Great 👍🏻 family place. Service was great.

Laura Garry via facebook.com - Feb 8, 2020

Really good barbecue. I was with ...

Really good barbecue. I was with a bunch of people on the way home from hunter mountain when we found this gem on yelp so we decided to try it out. We were glad we did.

They started us off with some corn bread which was amazing. Not too dry not too moist just perfect.

Then we got some fried pickles as an app which w ... read more

Demetri L. via yelp.com - Jan 25, 2020

I love coming here. The food is ...

I love coming here. The food is amazing. I love the spicy bbq wings and anything served from the pit. Walking in you can smell the food that has been roasting all day. The service is great and their homemade sauce is very good. Not a fan of the live music though. Too loud and not needed. They have a projector to broadcast games which ... read more

Bishoy B. via yelp.com - Jan 18, 2020

Great food and awesome people!! ...

Great food and awesome people!! Best fried pickles around! The bbq sauce is out of this world!! Yams are to die for!!

Summer H. via yelp.com - Jan 18, 2020

Service was awesome , very clean ...

Service was awesome , very clean , great food and atmosphere. Will definitely come back !

Josh T. via yelp.com - Dec 27, 2019

Best barbeque in the area, went ...

Best barbeque in the area, went friday night and the ribs were to die for. Definitely recommend and will go back ... read more

Thomas P. via yelp.com - Dec 21, 2019

Pleasant surprise

My family and I went to Brothers BBQ to celebrate my son’s birthday. The quantity and quality of the food was outstanding. We ordered two appetizers but probably shouldn’t have because we ordered the Eat Like a King dinner and it was more then the...More ... read more

jpnav via tripadvisor.com - Dec 13, 2019

Brisket is out of this world! Delish! ...

Brisket is out of this world! Delish! Great wait staff and reasonably priced. Local bands on Saturday nights. Call for reservations!

Irene S. via yelp.com - Dec 8, 2019

Very good however we're went on ...

Very good however we're went on a very busy weekend and since this wad my wife and my first date night since we're had our daughter we sadly didn't get to order the main item we went there for. Briscit :( ... read more

J P. via yelp.com - Dec 8, 2019

The best bbq place in town!!!! ...

The best bbq place in town!!!! Live music, yummy food like corn bread, meaty ribs and brisket!!!

Margarita C. via yelp.com - Dec 7, 2019

Came here tonight for an early ...

Came here tonight for an early dinner. My wife and I both had the fried chicken...wow it was some of the best I have ever had. The coleslaw was beyond terrific and the French fries were awesome! A great meal, fair prices and good service. Will definitely be back!

Gregg G. via yelp.com - Dec 6, 2019

The Hudson Valley's best BBQ

The Hudson Valley's best BBQ ... read more

Emil J Sullivan Jr. via facebook.com - Dec 6, 2019

Everything on the menu is amazing, especially the ribs , brisket and cornbread! The staff are frien

Everything on the menu is amazing, especially the ribs , brisket and cornbread! The staff are friendly and attentive. Always a great time.

Teresa Baker via facebook.com - Dec 6, 2019

Extremely friendly staff they went out of their way to make us happy.

Kelly Ann Gannuscio via facebook.com - Nov 23, 2019

Amazing food!! The best staff anywhere!! Live music what more could you ask for!!

Marjorie Morgan Sherwood via facebook.com - Nov 17, 2019

The best ribs I’ve had since Dallas, TX! The ribs were meaty tender and juicy, the BBQ tangy even t

The best ribs I’ve had since Dallas, TX! The ribs were meaty tender and juicy, the BBQ tangy even the Mac and cheese was delicious and the corn bread is generously free and sweet! I highly recommend this place for BBQ lovers. Staff was warm and friendly too.

Tania Sterl via facebook.com - Nov 10, 2019

Great BBQ!

My wife and I were in the mood for BBQ. Went on Saturday night and had to wait about 20 minutes for table. No a problem we got a beer at the bar. For dinner I had the brisket, absolutely delicious. Fresh warm cornbread as...More ... read more

777maxtech via tripadvisor.com - Nov 10, 2019

Food was excellent!! The best pulled pork and Mac n Cheese I have ever eaten!

Staci Carter Wishart via facebook.com - Nov 10, 2019

Cornbread. On. Point. Golden BBQ ...

Cornbread. On. Point. Golden BBQ smoked wings on deck. Tasty sauce and crispy! Got the "Eat Like a Brother" which comes with a full chicken, 2 racks of tender ribs, brisket, and pulled pork. Comes with a large slaw and 3 large sides so we got the candied yams mac n cheese and fries.

Post-Butter Hill Loop hike... which was abo ... read more

Jamie C. via yelp.com - Nov 3, 2019

Woweeeee where do I begin. I'm ...

Woweeeee where do I begin. I'm not sure how we've lived this close and just discover this place. The waiter ask if it was our first time to which we replied yes. He said y'all are in for a treat! Boy was he right. From the service to the food nothing but cornbread and pull-pork Heaven. Prices are just right and large portions will le ... read more

Dyani T. via yelp.com - Nov 1, 2019

This place is the best BBQ IN NEW ...

This place is the best BBQ IN NEW YORK!! I've lived in Kansas and Brothers BBQ is just as good if not better then all the places there. They have Guiness on Tap!!!!

Chris G. via yelp.com - Nov 1, 2019

Best BBQ around

If you are looking for amazing BBQ or even the best fried chicken sandwich of your life....visit Brothers. sometimes it gets pretty crowded but it is worth the wait!

khaleesi_ny17 via tripadvisor.com - Oct 31, 2019

Amazing Carolina style BBQ. I ordered ...

Amazing Carolina style BBQ. I ordered the chopped sandwich with sauce on the side. I like my bbq dry but seasoned with hot sauce and vinegar. My only issue was my cornbread tasted like it had been microwaved kind of tasted rubbery. Bathroom was really clean and inviting definitely going back soon. I need to try more items on the menu ... read more

Tomi C. via yelp.com - Oct 29, 2019

Simply just perfect, like a home feeling.

Keith Salberg via google.com - Oct 29, 2019

Awesome lunch today with my picky ...

Awesome lunch today with my picky girl...had sticky asian ribs that were quite tasty, maybe 10 perfectly cooked 8 x 1 in ribs presented in a pleasing stacked way. And smoked onion rings and corn bread to die for-with real butter. My girl had a shrimp po'boy which while good enough isnt something that should be on the menu imho. Shes ... read more

Jon B. via yelp.com - Oct 26, 2019

Great Home Cooking!

Cozy place to go on a cold rainy day as it were, great home style BBQ , best since I had down in North Carolina years back. This place is clean, great food, owner is there to be sure everything is perfect! Will be back...More ... read more

Steven A via tripadvisor.com - Oct 22, 2019

Good service nice atmosphere the food was amazing.

Eric Higgins via facebook.com - Oct 21, 2019

Ate here today with a big car group - they were kind enough to seat all of us and take care of us a

Ate here today with a big car group - they were kind enough to seat all of us and take care of us after our cruise today. Had the brisket with Cole Slaw and Cheesy grits - really tasty and good portion sizes! Thanks everyone!

Anthony Siciliano via facebook.com - Oct 21, 2019

Whatever you guys are doing, keep ...

Whatever you guys are doing, keep doing exactly the same from now on. The food yesterday was the best we've ever had. "Eat like a king" portions were amazing, ribs were amazing, everything was amazing. The fries are so good, not an afterthought or a filler, fries you can actually enjoy. Same for the coleslaw, it tasted like the one I ... read more

Autre O. via yelp.com - Oct 20, 2019

Decent. As far as barbecue experiences ...

Decent. As far as barbecue experiences go that would have to be the summary for this spot which is kind of disappointing as my expectations were high based off the yelp reviews I previewed before going. The ambiance of the place is nice. Although we did not arrive during a live event the stage and decor provided a homey vibe; as did ... read more

Bibi R. via yelp.com - Oct 15, 2019

The Best Barbeque Ever!!!

This place never disappoints. Everything I have ordered is delicious, down home cooking. Everything made from scratch from the fall off the bone baby back ribs to the mac and cheese. Don’t leave Orange County without stopping by here.

Josephine C via tripadvisor.com - Oct 15, 2019

Excellent food and service

Excellent food and service ... read more

Darlene Redic via facebook.com - Oct 14, 2019

This was the best barbecue I’ve ever had. I have to get back soon!

Frank Cirino via facebook.com - Oct 13, 2019

Food is amazing Work staff ...

Food is amazing

Work staff is great

Just took a tad bit to get our food I'd say...

Dub H. via yelp.com - Oct 12, 2019

great food and a friendly staff!

Cheryl Palmer via facebook.com - Oct 11, 2019

A close friend recommended this place and he was absolutely correct. The food is delicious and of h

A close friend recommended this place and he was absolutely correct. The food is delicious and of high quality.

Frank DiBattista via facebook.com - Sep 22, 2019

Really delish bbq, great southern style dishes. Great staff!

Richard Otero via facebook.com - Sep 21, 2019

Me and my co workers ordered food ...

Me and my co workers ordered food from here and I enjoyed it. I ordered their cheese stuffed burger and side of mac and cheese. Mac and cheese was good, but the burger was amazing. It was cooked well done for me just how I asked. I would order this again or maybe try out their ribs.

J R. via yelp.com - Sep 19, 2019

Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?

Reviews

Follow Us

Navigation

Hours

Contact