BROTHERS BARBECUE CATERING
Looking for unforgettable BBQ catering for your next event?
You just found it — Brothers Smokehouse Catering.
At Brothers, we’re all about real deal, finger-lickin’ BBQ that gets people talking. Whether it’s a backyard party, corporate event, wedding, or any special gathering, our smoked-to-perfection menu is built to impress.
The BBQ Lineup
Our pitmasters have spent years perfecting their craft. Every bite is smoky, juicy, and packed with flavor:
-
Slow-smoked ribs that fall off the bone
-
Tender pulled pork piled high
-
Juicy smoked chicken with crisp skin
-
Flavorful brisket that melts in your mouth
The Fixings
No BBQ is complete without the sides. From creamy mac & cheese and tangy coleslaw to buttery cornbread and savory baked beans, our sides bring the whole feast together.
Catering Made Easy
Every event is different — that’s why we offer customizable catering packages. Go big with a full-service buffet or keep it simple with drop-off delivery. Either way, our team takes care of the details so you can focus on having a good time.
How to Book
-
Catering available 6 days a week (closed Mondays)
-
We request at least 48 hours’ notice (a week is ideal)
-
Last-minute? Call us at 845-534-4BBQ (4227) and we’ll see what we can do
-
Catering packages start at groups of 20+
-
Smaller crew? Place a pickup order instead!
Don’t settle for ordinary BBQ. Let Brothers Smokehouse bring the flavor, the fun, and the smoke to your next event.
CATERING FAQ
Do you guys deliver?
We do! Delivery is based on Mileage up to 25 miles is $75 beyond that price increases.
How do I order?
Shoot an email to your local restaurant.
Cornwall NY - B.Wall@smokenallday.com
Ramsey NJ - j.galati@smokenallday.com
West Nyack NY - p.dacosta@smokenallday
How much food should I get??
Our half pans feed about 10-12 and full pans about 18-20. We recommend for every 20 people a full pan of protein and full pan of sides to feed everyone comfortably and some have seconds. If your getting a variety of proteins or sides, unsure how much to order give our team a call and we can help you curate the perfect menu.
Do you do weddings?
Send us an email. We're happy to discuss what's possible.
Cornwall NY - B.Wall@smokenallday.com
Ramsey NJ - j.galati@smokenallday.com
West Nyack NY - p.dacosta@smokenallday
Do you provide warmers to keep food hot?
Yes we can provide for $20 a setup
catering menu
Prices subject to change anytime
Catering Menu Early Bird
SMOKED MEATS
Pulled Pork
Half Pan
$100.00
Full Pan
$180.00
Smoked Chicken
Half Pan
$85.00
Full Pan
$160.00
Brisket
Half Pan
$150.00
Full Pan
$290.00
Aunt Edna's Fried Chicken
Half Pan
$85.00
Full Pan
$160.00
Shrimp
Beaufort, Fried, Grilled and Cocktail $23.99 Per Dozen (Minimum 3 Dozen)
$23.99
Chopped BBQ
Half Pan
$100.00
Full Pan
$180.00
Ribs
Choice of Baby Racks or St. Louis
Half Pan
$120.00
Full Pan
$235.00
Smoked Sausage
Half Pan
$100.00
Full Pan
$190.00
Wings
Spicy BBQ, BBQ, Mild, Hot, Garlic Thyme, Smoken Hot, Lemon Pepper (featured)
Half Pan
$70.00
Full Pan
$135.00
MADE FROM SCRATCH SIDES
Brothers Famous Mac N Cheese
Half Pan
$80.00
Full Pan
$110.00
Southern Green Beans
Half Pan
$65.00
Full Pan
$90.00
Smoked Beans
Half Pan
$65.00
Full Pan
$90.00
Cheese Grits
Half Pan
$65.00
Full Pan
$90.00
Fresh Cut Slaw
Half Pan
$45.00
Full Pan
$65.00
Big Jay's Collard
Half Pan
$65.00
Full Pan
$90.00
Candied Yams
Half Pan
$65.00
Full Pan
$90.00
Fresh Cut Fries
Half Pan
$65.00
Full Pan
$90.00
Potato Salad
Half Pan
$65.00
Full Pan
$90.00
Cornbread
Half Pan
$50.00
Full Pan
$75.00
Salad
Brothers Greens, Brothers Caesar
Half Pan
$40.00
Full Pan
$60.00
Offsite Catering
Brothers Barbecue is proud to offer off-premise catering, bringing the same high-quality food and hospitality you know from our restaurants straight to your event. For parties of 50 or more, our team provides live cooking at your location and sets up a self-serve buffet designed to impress your guests.
Looking to impress your guests with a whole smoked hog slow-cooked to tender perfection? Brothers has you covered. With over 15 years of experience, we know there’s nothing quite like the flavor of a whole hog done right.
We brine, season, and slow-smoke fresh hogs, then deliver them to your home with a beautiful, convenient display. Our famous BBQ sauce is included, and chopped BBQ is available upon request.
Please note: we require a 50-person minimum and add a 20% gratuity.
Add-On Pricing (per person):
• Additional Meat: $5.95
• Additional Hot Side: $2.50
• Additional Cold Side: $1.50
At your chosen location, we fire up the charcoal to cook Sabrett hot dogs and gourmet cheeseburgers, along with your choice of two smoked meats, two hot sides, one cold side, and cornbread.
Your package also includes paper products, cutlery, serving spoons, and condiments. Our team arrives approximately 45 minutes to 1 hour before serving time to set up a self-serve buffet, which we staff for one hour. At the end of service, we restock the buffet with any remaining food, then handle the breakdown, cleanup, and exit.
We kick off your celebration by slow-smoking a fresh hog at our restaurant in preparation for your event. On the day of, our team arrives at your chosen location to set up and display the pig, while also grilling Sabrett hot dogs and gourmet cheeseburgers. Your package includes your choice of two smoked meats, two hot sides, one cold side, and cornbread.
We provide all necessary paper products, cutlery, serving spoons, and condiments. Our team will arrive approximately 45 minutes to 1 hour before serving time to set up a self-serve buffet, which we attend for one hour. At the conclusion of service, we restock the buffet with any remaining food, then handle the full breakdown, cleanup, and exit.
Beverages are available at an additional $5 per person and include water, Coke, Sprite, and Diet Coke, with the option to substitute other beverages upon request. Please note there is a 50-person minimum for all service packages, along with an added 20% gratuity and applicable tax.
Request a Quote
Please take a moment to fill out the form.